New TNS and Survation Scottish polls

Share

There were two new polls on the Scottish Parliament elections today - a new TNS face-to-face poll and a new Survation online poll. Note that while they are both newly published the different methodologies mean that the Survation fieldwork is far newer than TNS's

- Survation polled over the weekend, TNS polled over the last three weeks. Topline figures are below:

Survation Constituency vote: SNP 54%, LAB 21%, CON 16%, LDEM 5% Regional vote: SNP 43%, LAB 19%, CON 14%, LDEM 7%, GRN 9%, UKIP 6%

TNS: Constituency vote: SNP 60%, LAB 21%, CON 13%, LDEM 4% Regional vote: SNP 55%, LAB 21%, CON 13%, LDEM 4%, GRN 6%

Both polls have a huge SNP lead and their victory in May seems a foregone conclusion. Labour are comfortably in second place - the last round of Scottish Parliament polling from TNS showed the gap between Labour and the Conservatives narrowing, but that has faded away again. The Survation poll has UKIP up at 6%, which has provoked some comment - it appears to be something to do with Survation's methodology rather than a new development, looking back over past Scottish Parliament polling Survation have consistently had UKIP at 5-6% in the Holyrood regional vote while other companies consistently give them between 1-3%. John Curtice has speculated that this may be something to do with the question wording Survation use, which refers to the regional vote as a "second vote" and might lead to some people giving a second preference (this would also explain the big gap they fond between SNP constituency and regional vote). A couple of years ago Roger Scully did an experiment looking at different wordings in Welsh Assembly polling, and found you got really different answers depending on whether the question said "second vote" or "regional vote", so it is plausible that there's a similar effect in Scotland.